René Gabriel
92: A fairly decent wine, but unfortunately its relationship to Mouton can only be detected in trace elements. 03: Has held up well despite its rather light build. (15/20). 08: Garnet with fairly dark highlights. Earthy bouquet, autumn forest floor, baking chocolate notes, quite deep but without sweetness. On the palate, sinewy, muscular, meaty, bourgeois, tending toward a certain hardness; more of a table wine. (16/20). 10: Dark wine red with a brick-red tinge. Dry, earthy, oddly showing green Cabernet notes for an ’82; great spice with dried kitchen herbs, peat and tobacco. Meaty palate, quite compact, showing surprising concentration; tannins a bit mellow, which makes it feel somewhat bourgeois. (17/20). 12: Sound garnet, showing only a very fine touch of maturity at the rim. Black plum skins, liquorice, black trumpets, dry, deep—somehow the message doesn’t quite come through despite the indicated depth. Meaty, little developed, comes across as quite robust. A food Pauillac with plenty of edges.