René Gabriel
New arrival (16/20): ripe Amarena cherry nose, dark chocolate; spicy with hidden traces of volatile acidity. On the palate, noble bitterness, dark chocolate, cocoa with barely perceptible, firm-grained tannins. The similarly firm bitterness on the palate could also come from barrel wood not fully dried out. A double magnum 1995: powerful bouquet; almost like an ’82 (equally full-bodied), it shows drive yet remains closed. On the palate also dense, hard in the tannins, bourgeois; the tannins still seem too dry from the barrique “ordeal.” 98: deep garnet; richly filled in the middle. Smoky bouquet, a hint of volatile acidity, then becoming ever fatter and denser, lots of dried fruits, prunes and licorice. On the palate meaty, rich extract, classic St. Emilion terroir aroma, fine-sandy flow, plenty of power and great length (17/20). 01: still very dark color, yet with a fine orange rim. Dry nose reminiscent of a quite grand Tuscan; sun-dried tomatoes, prunes, a lovely fruit sweetness, tending a bit toward dryness. On the palate medium-weight, slightly firm-grained tannins that tie in with the active acidity, raspberry seeds; despite evolution, it still shows strict and sandy in texture. It will never develop charm, but it allows the claim that it will live for a long time. 17/20 drink – 2008